The Buyer Offers $4 Million. The Seller Wants $5 Million. Can an Earn-Out Close the Gap?
Imagine a business owner in Westchester County who has spent 20 years building a successful specialty manufacturing company.
The business has consistent customers, experienced employees and a strong reputation. The owner believes it is worth $5 million.
A prospective buyer reviews the financial records and offers $4 million.
The buyer has a concern: a significant portion of the company’s expected future revenue depends on two large customer relationships. The buyer likes the business but is not entirely confident those customers will remain after the ownership transition.
The seller disagrees. They believe the customer relationships are strong and that revenue will continue growing.
Rather than walking away, both sides discuss an earn-out.
The buyer proposes paying $4 million at closing, with the possibility of an additional $1 million if the company achieves agreed performance targets over the next two years.
This is the basic idea behind an earn-out: part of the purchase price is paid later, depending on whether specified conditions are achieved.
How the Negotiation Could Work?
The buyer and seller agree on a hypothetical structure:
| Payment component | Amount |
| Payment at closing | $4,000,000 |
| Potential earn-out payment | $1,000,000 |
| Maximum potential purchase price | $5,000,000 |
The additional $1 million is not guaranteed. The seller must meet the agreed conditions to receive it.
For example, the parties might agree that the seller receives:
- $500,000 if the business generates at least $6 million in qualifying annual revenue during the first measurement period.
- Another $500,000 if it reaches an agreed earnings target during the second measurement period.
These are illustrative terms, not standard market requirements. Actual earn-out calculations can be based on revenue, gross profit, EBITDA, customer retention or other measurable performance indicators.
The parties must also agree on the measurement periods, accounting policies, payment dates and treatment of exceptional circumstances.
Why Would a Seller Agree to an Earn-Out?
For the seller, an earn-out can create an opportunity to receive additional consideration when the buyer is unwilling to pay the full requested price upfront.
It may be useful when:
- The business has strong growth potential that is not yet reflected in historical financial results.
- A major customer relationship is expected to continue but the buyer wants evidence.
- The seller believes recent investments will produce future results.
- The buyer and seller have different expectations about the company’s future performance.
However, sellers should be careful. An earn-out is not the same as receiving the full purchase price at closing.
The seller may have to wait months or years for the additional payment, and the payment may never become due.
Why Would a Buyer Propose an Earn-Out?
From the buyer’s perspective, an earn-out can reduce the risk of paying for future performance that does not materialize.
Consider a software company in Manhattan that has recently signed several new customers. The seller believes those contracts will create substantial recurring revenue. The buyer, however, wants to see whether customers renew and continue paying after the acquisition.
An earn-out tied to customer retention or qualifying revenue could help bridge that difference.
The buyer may also want the seller to remain involved during a transition period. In that situation, the agreement should clearly distinguish earn-out conditions from any separate employment, consulting or transition arrangement.
An earn-out can help align expectations, but it does not automatically eliminate the buyer’s risk.
The Five Negotiation Points That Matter Most
The headline earn-out amount is only one part of the agreement. The details determine whether the arrangement is practical and enforceable.
1. What performance measure will trigger payment?
Revenue is relatively straightforward to measure, but it does not necessarily indicate profitability. EBITDA may better reflect operating performance, but its calculation can be affected by accounting judgments and the allocation of expenses.
The parties should choose a measure that reflects the actual concern behind the earn-out.
2. How will performance be calculated?
The agreement should define the accounting policies, treatment of unusual expenses, customer credits, acquisitions, discontinued operations and other relevant adjustments.
Avoid relying on vague language such as “normal business earnings.”
3. Who controls the business after closing?
This is one of the biggest concerns for sellers.
After the transaction, the buyer generally controls the company. Decisions about pricing, staffing, marketing, investment and operations may affect whether the earn-out target is achieved.
The agreement should address how the business will be operated during the earn-out period and whether any specific restrictions or protections apply.
4. When will payments be made?
The parties should establish measurement dates, reporting deadlines, payment deadlines and a process for resolving disputes.
A seller should also understand what happens if the buyer sells the business, restructures it or combines it with another company before the earn-out period ends.
5. What happens if the parties disagree?
The agreement should include a clear process for reviewing calculations and resolving disputes. This may involve access to supporting records, objection deadlines and an independent accounting expert.
A New York transaction attorney should draft or review these provisions before the purchase agreement is signed.
A Warning for Sellers: The Additional $1 Million May Never Arrive
Return to the Westchester manufacturing company.
The seller agrees to the $4 million closing payment and the potential $1 million earn-out.
However, after closing, the buyer changes the company’s pricing strategy and shifts some major customers to another business within its group. The company misses the agreed revenue target.
The seller believes the buyer’s decisions affected the result. The buyer argues that the business simply failed to meet the contractual target.
This type of disagreement can become expensive and time-consuming if the agreement does not clearly address operational control, reporting and calculation methods.
Before accepting an earn-out, sellers should consider whether the performance targets are realistically achievable under the buyer’s expected operating plans.
It is also worth negotiating a reasonable payment structure that does not depend entirely on decisions outside the seller’s control.
Should You Accept an Earn-Out When Selling Your Business?
An earn-out may be worth considering when the buyer and seller have different expectations about future performance.
But it should not be accepted simply because the headline purchase price looks attractive.
Compare the following:
| Question | What the seller should consider |
| How much is paid at closing? | Can you accept this amount without relying on future payments? |
| What triggers the earn-out? | Are the targets measurable and realistic? |
| Who controls operations? | Can the buyer’s decisions affect your ability to earn the payment? |
| How long does it last? | Are you comfortable waiting for the additional consideration? |
| How are disputes resolved? | Is there a clear process for challenging calculations? |
An experienced business broker, transaction attorney and accountant can help assess whether the proposed structure reflects the risks and commercial realities of the deal.
What This Means for Business Owners Across New York?
Earn-outs can arise in many types of transactions, including manufacturing, distribution, technology, professional services and other privately held businesses.
For example, a buyer acquiring a distribution company in Nassau County may be concerned about customer retention. A buyer evaluating a professional services firm in Manhattan may focus on whether clients remain after the founder leaves. In Suffolk County or Orange County, future performance may depend on contracts, recurring customer relationships or expansion plans.
Business owners considering a sale in these markets should understand the difference between the agreed purchase price and the amount that is actually guaranteed at closing.
Explore our local business sale resources:
- Beacon, NY
- Bronx County, NY
- Brooklyn, NY
- Dutchess County, NY
- Long Island, NY
- Manhattan, NY
- New York City, NY
- Nassau County, NY
- Orange County, NY
- Queens County, NY
- Suffolk County, NY
- White Plains, NY
- Westchester County, NY
Understand Your Business’s Value Before Negotiating
An earn-out can influence how a buyer and seller structure a transaction, but it should not replace a realistic understanding of the company’s current value.
Before entering negotiations, consider obtaining an informed estimate based on the company’s financial performance, customer relationships, management structure, industry and market conditions.
Start with our Free Business Valuation Calculator or learn more about our Business Valuation Services.
If you are considering selling a business in New York and want to understand your options, contact Lisiten Associates to discuss your plans.